top of page

The possibility of thinking sound before sound

Anatoly Ryasov on sound in silent films, 'Barely audible hum: an introduction to the philosophy of sound' (translated from Russian):

'In the era of silent films, Garbo had as many voices as her army of fans could imagine. Sound cinema, on the other hand, limited her to one - her own <...> husky and with a Swedish accent". [219]," notes Sion. But the endless, hidden speech still continues to ripple beneath the unstructured footage, and this silent rumble contains a genuine grandeur. It seems to be the one that allows us to talk about the ontology of cinema. Silent films unequivocally pointed to a problem that had previously remained on the periphery, and was later forgotten altogether: the possibility of thinking sound before sound. The music that accompanied these pictures was nothing like interpretation, it did not dispel the enormous ambiguity, but rather exacerbated it. But a few decades have passed and even film music has less and less recourse to the principle of counterpoint, preferring to emphasise emotional states and turning into an obligatory banality - an innocent sound interior.'
2 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Suppose you want to bring down the area

William Burroughs prophesies Twitter more than 30 years before it was invented: suppose you want to bring down the area go in and record all the ugliest stupidest dialogue the most discordant sound tr

The past never gives us direct access to the past

'Nevertheless, Early Music is potentially this kind of performance practice or listening experience which doesn't believe in the so-called original, authentic experience of the contemporary moment, bu


I keep hearing the same argument in the West regarding Ukraine's problematic past, both the second world war and a more recent one. As if it justifies the atrocities Russia is committing in Ukraine's


bottom of page